junkbarbarian wrote:B. I resolve both shots, and the second guy (missed but outgunned by the semi auto) ducks back. Then the guy with the STG44 returns fire.
This. Your GI won the In Sight so he gets to act first, and his action consists of two shots because he has a semi auto. (Technically the Duck Back and the Return Fire happen simultaneously)
Shoulda put both shots into the SG44: the rifleman isn't targeted, so he won't Return Fire, and if you take out the SG44 the other guy takes a Man Down test at half strength...
(which, when you think about it, is probably what you'd do in reality, ie. focus on the bigger threat)
(As a personal aside, I don't play it that the M1 Garand outguns a single-shot bolt action rifle in my games - it makes it unrealistically easy for a single GI to drive off (outgun) a pair of Grenadiers, IMO. It gets enough of an advantage as it it with that extra shot...)